Checklist / Colic & Fussiness

The Ultimate Colic & Fussiness Checklist for Dads

Ryan · Degen DadUpdated Sep 19, 2026

If your baby cries for hours every day, seemingly for no reason, at roughly the same time, and nothing you do makes it stop — welcome to colic. It's not your fault. You're not doing anything wrong. Your baby is not broken. But it will break your spirit if you're not prepared. This checklist won't cure colic, because nothing really does, but it gives you a game plan for getting through it.

Use this checklist when your baby's fussiness feels like more than normal crying — especially if it's 3+ hours a day, 3+ days a week. Revisit the self-care section when you're at your limit.

0 of 24 completed0%

Rule Out the Fixable Stuff First

Check if baby is hungry, even if they just ateMust have

Growth spurts, cluster feeding, comfort nursing — babies sometimes need to eat way more than the schedule says. Offer food first. It's the easiest fix.

Check the diaper — wet, dirty, or rashMust have

A dirty diaper or a rash that stings can cause nonstop crying. Quick check, quick fix. Rule it out before moving to harder solutions.

Check for a hair tourniquet on fingers or toesMust have

A single hair wrapped around a finger or toe cuts off circulation and causes serious pain. Undress baby completely and check every digit. This is more common than you think.

Check clothing for tags, snaps, or elastic digging into skinRecommended

A snap poking their belly or a tag scratching their neck can cause persistent crying. Undress them and see if the crying stops. Babies can't point to what hurts.

Take baby's temperature if the crying seems different than usualMust have

Fever over 100.4°F in a baby under 3 months is an ER visit. If the crying sounds different — more high-pitched, more intense, more panicked — trust your gut and check.

Consider gas — bicycle legs, belly massage, gas dropsMust have

Lay baby on back and gently cycle their legs like pedaling a bike. Press knees gently toward belly. Gas drops (simethicone) are safe and sometimes help. Burp more during feeds.

The 5 S's Soothing System

Swaddle — snug wrapping calms the startle reflexMust have

A tight swaddle (arms down) mimics the womb. Use a swaddle sack if your wrapping skills are questionable. Arms should be snug but hips loose.

Side/Stomach position — hold baby on their side or stomach on your forearmMust have

The football hold — face down on your forearm with head at your elbow, hand between legs. This is for holding only. Always put them on their back to sleep.

Shush — loud, continuous white noise near their earMust have

The womb is loud — like a vacuum cleaner. Your 'shh' needs to be louder than you think. A white noise machine cranked up works too. Gentle shushing does nothing for peak colic.

Swing — rhythmic movement, not gentle rockingMust have

Small, jiggly movements, not big swings. Support the head and do quick, tiny bounces. Like you're gently jiggling Jell-O. The movement needs to be faster than you think.

Suck — offer a pacifier or clean finger to suck onMust have

Sucking triggers the calming reflex. If baby takes a pacifier, this can be your most powerful tool. If they refuse it, try different shapes or a clean pinky finger.

Use all 5 simultaneously for maximum effectMust have

One S alone might not work. Swaddle + side hold + shushing + swinging + sucking at the same time is the full system. It's a lot but it's designed to stack.

Environmental & Dietary Strategies

Try reducing stimulation during fussy periodsRecommended

Dim lights, quiet room, no visitors, no TV. Some babies are overstimulated by the end of the day and need sensory input dialed way down.

Go outside — a change of scenery helps sometimesRecommended

Fresh air and outdoor sounds are different enough from indoor noise to break the crying cycle. Even standing on the porch for 5 minutes can reset things.

Try a warm bath during peak fussy timeRecommended

Warm water relaxes tense muscles and changes the sensory environment. It doesn't always work but when it does, it's magical.

If breastfeeding, consider if mom's diet might be a factorRecommended

Dairy is the most common culprit. Talk to the pediatrician before eliminating anything. It takes 2-3 weeks to see if removing a food helps. Don't try this without medical guidance.

Try probiotics — ask your pediatrician about Lactobacillus reuteriRecommended

Some studies show specific probiotic strains reduce colic crying. Not guaranteed but the risk is low. Always check with your doctor before giving baby any supplement.

Motion — car rides, stroller walks, bouncing on an exercise ballMust have

The car ride at 2 AM is a colic dad cliche because it works. The vibration and white noise of a car puts babies to sleep. An exercise ball in the living room is the home version.

Protecting Your Sanity

It is always okay to put baby down in a safe place and walk awayMust have

Crib, door closed, go to another room, breathe for 5 minutes. A crying baby in a safe crib is fine. A parent at their breaking point is dangerous. This is not abandonment — it's self-regulation.

Tag team with your partner — set time limits for holding dutyMust have

45-minute shifts. When your time is up, hand baby off and go decompress. No guilt. Colic is an endurance event and you need to pace yourself.

Wear noise-reducing earbuds while holding babyRecommended

You can still hear the baby cry — just at a lower volume. This is not ignoring them. It's protecting your nervous system so you can continue to be present. Loop earplugs or similar.

Talk to someone — friend, family, therapist, your pediatricianMust have

Prolonged crying triggers real stress responses in adults. Irritability, rage, hopelessness — these are normal reactions to abnormal levels of crying. You are not failing.

Remind yourself daily: colic peaks around 6 weeks and resolves by 3-4 monthsMust have

There is an end date. It doesn't feel like it at 11 PM when they've been screaming for 3 hours, but this is temporary. Most colic is done by 4 months. You will get through this.

Never shake your baby, no matter how frustrated you areMust have

This needs to be said plainly. Shaking a baby can cause brain damage or death. If you feel rage building, put baby down and leave the room. Call someone. There is no shame in needing help.

Dad Pro Tips

#1The 'colic hold' — baby face-down on your forearm with gentle pressure on their belly — works for gas-related fussiness. Your forearm warmth plus the gentle pressure helps them pass gas. Walk around slowly while holding them this way.
#2Record a video of your baby's worst crying episode to show the pediatrician. Describing 'inconsolable screaming' in a calm office visit doesn't convey the reality. A 30-second video says more than any description.
#3If you have a dryer, put baby's swaddle blanket in for 2 minutes on low heat before wrapping them. The warmth mimics being held and can calm them down faster than a room-temperature swaddle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is colic caused by something I'm doing wrong?

No. Colic is not caused by bad parenting, bad formula, or anything you did or didn't do. The exact cause is unknown, but it affects babies across all feeding methods, parenting styles, and socioeconomic groups. It's a developmental phase that some babies go through. You're not the problem, and there's nothing you could have done to prevent it.

Do gas drops and gripe water actually work?

Simethicone gas drops (Mylicon) are safe and may help if gas is contributing to discomfort. Clinical evidence is mixed. Gripe water ingredients vary by brand — some contain sugar, fennel, or ginger. Some parents report improvement, others see no difference. Neither will hurt your baby when used as directed, so they're worth trying, but don't expect a miracle cure.

Will colic affect my baby's development?

No. Research consistently shows that babies who had colic develop normally. Once colic resolves, there are no lasting effects on temperament, behavior, or cognitive development. The short-term impact is primarily on the parents, not the baby. Your colicky baby will grow into a perfectly normal kid who has zero memory of those screaming months.

When should I take my colicky baby to the ER?

Go to the ER if the crying is accompanied by fever (100.4+ in babies under 3 months), vomiting, bloody stool, the baby is limp or unresponsive between crying bouts, there's a visible injury, or the crying has a sudden quality change that feels different from normal colic episodes. Trust your gut. If something feels wrong beyond 'my baby cries a lot,' get it checked.

How do I deal with people who say 'enjoy every moment'?

You don't have to enjoy colic. Nobody enjoys colic. It's okay to love your baby and simultaneously hate this phase. The people who say 'enjoy every moment' either don't remember or never had a colicky baby. Acknowledge the hard parts honestly. Surviving colic is an accomplishment. You don't need to pretend you're having fun.